Final report: Audi Q2 1.4TFSI 150 S-Tronic S Line
24 September 2018
Author: Debbie Wood
Final Update: Small but mighty
When we first took delivery of the Q2 at the beginning of the year, I was sceptical that this fashionable, compact SUV could be more 'style than substance'.
But after six months and 5,072 miles, the smallest member of Audi's growing SUV family has well and truly proved me wrong. Its fun and quirky exterior looks are complemented by a good-quality cabin, the latest technology and a great all-round engine.
Small SUVs are hot property right now, and the Q2 was one of the first to enter the fold when it arrived in the UK at the end of 2016. It's hardly old, but many competitors have recently entered the sector, making the marketplace fiercely competitive.
There are a number of attributes that help the Q2 stand out against its rivals, such as the four-ringed badge that has oodles of premium appeal. It's definitely caught the attention of many people in my home village, as well as admiration from my family and friends. The Vegas Yellow paintwork has been divisive - as we have discussed in a previous report - but it gets a resounding thumbs up from the granitekitchen team.
The Q2 offers a smaller 1.0-litre petrol, a 1.6-litre and 2.0-litre diesel, and the engine we eventually settled on, a 1.4-litre petrol paired with the firm's seven-speed s-tronic gearbox. It costs around £1,500 more for the automatic and we could not recommend it highly enough; if you're on a budget and only considering a few upgrades, this one should definitely be on your list.
The timely and smooth gear changes are perfectly in tune with the engine, making for an excellent pairing. Plus the gearbox comes with a sporty 'S' mode and shift paddles, if you fancy a more racy drive home.
Petrol has been making a resurgence in fleets, mainly due to the uncertainty surrounding the old fleet-favourite, diesel. This 1.4 unit has been a joy to drive and proved versatile, impressing out on the motorway and in the city. The light and responsive steering made easy work of the tight city streets and its all-round visibility is good too, thanks to that trademark SUV higher seating position.
Like all Audi cars, the cabin offers premium materials and excellent quality throughout. Despite being 13cm shorter than the A3 Sportback, with which it shares many of its underpinnings, the inside felt spacious enough for a family of four. When it comes to boot space, 405 litres proved big enough for everyday life, accommodating a modern baby-travel system, with room to spare for a few bags of shopping. When you head on holiday there could be a few issues though - especially if you have very small children - as prams and travel systems leave little space for suitcases and larger bags; we had to be very disciplined when we travelled to the coast for a week.
Our only bugbear was with equipment. It was disappointing to see dual-zone climate control, heated seats and reversing camera all missing from this top-of-the-range S Line car. Granted, options are pretty cheap by Audi's standards, but we'd have liked a few more luxuries.
Among our favourite options we came upon was wireless charging - which is definitely a must for anyone with a modern phone - while features like Audi's Virtual Cockpit, the upgraded sat-nav and park assist continued to impress.
It's a car that has proven to be fashionable and functional during its time with us - and manages to pull on the heartstrings too.
P11D price: £28,795
As tested: £32,620
Official consumption: 52.3mpg
Our average consumption: 42.4mpg
Update 9: Four rings to rule them all
There are very few things us Brits like to think that Germans do better. One might be sausages - unless you're from Lincolnshire like me - another could be classical music as Germany is the birthplace of Bach and Beethoven, and the other is likely to be cars.
German manufacturers dominate the sales charts when it comes to the premium market, with firms like Audi, BMW and Mercedes-Benz lapping up the lion's share of sales.
Owning a premium German car is something of a status symbol and even entry models like our Q2 here command a certain amount of respect. You're certainly not going to be ashamed waving your keys around at a friend's dinner party.
In the compact SUV segment, there are still few competitors for the Q2, which instead pitches itself against the Mini Countryman, Mercedes-Benz GLA and BMW X1, all larger than the Q2 with higher price tags.
Arguably the most youthful and characterful of its rivals here, the Q2 happily makes sense on paper too.
Our car's 37.5% residual value slightly beats the Mini Countryman's 37.2%, while the Mercedes is superior with residual values over 43% and the X1 comes in at 40%. However, because of the Audi's cheaper P11D, whole-life costs are the best of the bunch at 63.3p, with the Mercedes closest behind at 63.9p per-mile.
As we've discussed in previous reports, the Q2 can easily cope with the demands of a small family; there's plenty of space upfront, meanwhile, rear space is more than suitable for children.
It's in the boot where you'll probably feel the squeeze most, with the X1 (505 litres) and Mercedes GLA (481 litres) significantly bigger than the Q2's 405 litres. Then there's the BMW X2, brand new for 2018 and arguably a closer rival to the Q2, also bigger at 470 litres.
But size isn't everything and there's only been one camping holiday where we've really had to ration what we packed to make it fit during our custodianship. And that has more to do with travelling with a small child that needs a travel system, travel cot, steriliser and three or four outfits per day 'just in case'.
During the past six months, the Q2 hasn't missed a beat and we're dreading handing the keys back in a couple of weeks time.
Audi Q2 1.4TFSI 150 S-Tronic S Line
P11D price £28,795
As tested £32,620
Official consumption 52.3mpg
Our average consumption 42.3mpg
Update 8: Motorway marathon
Rewind ten years and the idea that a 1.4-litre petrol engine would be a good choice for the motorway would have seemed pretty far-fetched. Diesel equaled long distance motorway travel and petrol was considered best for city dwellers. It was as simple as that.
Although most diesels still have the economy edge on long-distance motorway treks, the 1.4-litre petrol under our Q2's bonnet is more suited to life on the motorway than you might think, largely thanks to advancements in petrol engines over the past decade and the arrival of Audi's cylinder-on-demand (CoD) technology - first introduced more than five years ago.
When cruising on the motorway or dual carriageway, the CoD technology is in its element. The system automatically deactivates two of the engines four cylinders when not needed, allowing the car to cruise more smoothly at high speeds, while also saving valuable fuel.
As the deactivation is only temporary, if the driver wants extra momentum to overtake or enter the motorway on a slip road, all four cylinders will kick back into life pretty seamlessly when you put your foot down on the accelerator pedal.
Offering up 150hp and 250Nm of torque, there's more than enough pull to gain speed quickly and the characterful engine is eager to rev. It's economical too, averaging around 43mpg over the past 4,000 miles.
Adaptive cruise control (a £375 option) is at hand to make motorway travel even easier and more rela, keeping the car at your set pace and automatically slowing and speeding the car back up again to adapt to the traffic.
Comfort is obviously key when travelling on the motorway and admittedly the suspension in the Q2 isn't as good as your average D-segment saloon or family hatch, but it does a reasonable job of swallowing tarmac imperfections, while road, engine and wind noise is kept to a minimum.
Other comfort features like heated seats and dual-zone climate control need to be added from the options list, but are not too expensive to include.
We're coming close to the end of our time with the Q2, and Audi's smallest SUV is proving to be the consummate all-rounder.
Our average fuel consumption: 42.4mpg
Update 7: Colour preference
I knew choosing our long-termer in Vegas yellow paintwork was going to be a divisive choice and it hasn't disappointed.
"I really like the Q2 but.."
"It's a really nice car except.."
These are two phrases I hear a lot from my family and friends. And it still amazes me that no matter how big the price tag, or how impressive the technology, or what the badge says on the front, people are still instantly turned off if they don't like the colour.
But what hasn't really surprised me, and will probably make Audi happy given the Q2's target audience, is that yellow is a big hit with the younger members of my family, in particular my teenage stepdaughter. The older generation (my husband, dad and brother-in-law especially), not so much.
Historically, colour choice can have an impact on used values too, with certain shades proving harder to sell at auction. Here at granitekitchen, we've become big fans of the Vegas yellow paintwork, and the good news is that we spoke to residual value experts at KeeResources and they believe colour choice isn't as big a deterrent as it used to be, especially for premium cars like our long-termer here.
Buyers may need to expect to pay more for bright colours, which bodes well for used values, meanwhile a premium brand can usually carry a bolder colour, as even if fashions change, the underlying value is still about the brand strengths.
That doesn't mean a premium car is protected from any fashion-related impact of course - we've all seen those terrible eyelashes on headlights or a dodgy leather interior choice - but they are better protected than most.
Options can sometimes be on the pricey side at Audi, but the £550 extra cost for the solid bright yellow paintwork is actually very reasonable in our eyes and delivers an extra dose of character to the car. We're well over the halfway point with the Q2 now and it still raises a smile that when we enter busy car parks it never fails to turn people's heads.
Our average fuel consumption: 41.8mpg
Update 6: Cabin appeal
Hardly an issue of granitekitchen goes by without us talking about how quickly technology is evolving. The rate at which new kit comes to market is simply staggering. Recent years have seen the introduction of Nissan's e-pedal, Volvo's self-driving tech and BMW's gesture control, to name but a few.
Today, cars can park (and pretty much drive) themselves, you can charge your phone without using a cable and speak to the car to access functions. The latest sat-nav and infotainment systems can seemingly think for themselves too, modifying choices and locations to mirror our habits and tastes.
We drove Audi's flagship car, the A8, in late 2017 and were blown away by the level of advanced tech on offer. Although our Q2 doesn't quite offer the same level of high-tech features as its stablemate, it still impresses when it comes to modern kit.
Highlights include wireless charging if you've got an up-to-date phone, the excellent Virtual Cockpit and an autonomous parking system.
Audi's Virtual Cockpit was first launched in the TT in 2014 and mimics most of the information available through the car's main infotainment screen. The resolution is crisp and the system is so easy to navigate around, even safety fanatics will struggle to argue that it's distracting for the driver.
Because you can have the infotainment screen and the Virtual Cockpit displaying different features at the same time, the driver can have more information on show. For example, I like to listen to Spotify while on the move, so I can have the app open on the main screen via Apple CarPlay, which is standard on our car. In the meantime, I can keep the sat-nav directions and the map showing through the Virtual Cockpit. It sounds simple but it makes a big difference.
The sat-nav is advanced and includes traffic updates, adjusting the timings and rerouting accordingly. It also clearly shows on the map where roads are closed and congestion is building, whether you're heading in that direction or not. If you travel as many miles as I do, especially around the M25, kit like this is essential to avoid getting stuck in traffic. I actually prefer Audi's own sat-nav system to Apple CarPlay and Google Maps - something I cannot say for most systems currently available on the market.
Most of these features form part of the Technology Pack, which is the most expensive, but is still a good value for money option on our Q2 at £1,395 and incorporates the Virtual Cockpit display, wireless charging and the upgraded sat-nav system.
To activate the sat-nav, you can use voice control, the rotary dial or the touchpad system on top of the dial to insert destinations. For the most part, the touchpad works well, only sometimes getting confused between numbers and letters like '0' and 'o' or '1' and 'I'. If you have dumpy fingers like me (thanks, Dad) you may accidentally end up inputting a 'g' that gets mistaken for a 'q' - but, thankfully, it's easy to delete mistakes.
I've found voice control a little temperamental to use, but my husband raves about it, finding little fault in the system at all. The rotary dial is still my preferred way of getting around the infotainment system - probably showing my age.
Audi designers were keen to make the Q2 appeal to a younger - more hip - generation and, although design is part of the solution, technology plays a big role in attracting millennial buyers. While it might not be as technologically brilliant as the A8, the Q2 costs around £50,000 less and offers buyers a slice of modern technology, which is well executed and comes at an affordable price.
Our average fuel consumption: 41.9mpg
Update 5: Sporting effort
Our long-term Audi Q2 certainly knows how to grab the attention of passersby, but we all know there needs to be more to a car than those eye-catching looks. After all, for any keen driver, what lies under the bonnet will rank even higher on the priority list.
This member of the granitekitchen stable is fitted with a 1.4-litre petrol engine with 150hp, 250Nm of torque, and Cylinder on Demand technology, which essentially deactivates two of the engine's four cylinders when not needed, to keep economy respectable. Impressively, the engine is so refined that you'd struggle to notice when this wizardry is taking place, though.
Official economy figures are pretty good as a result, with a combined figure of 52.3mpg and CO2 emissions of 123g/km. Despite the green credentials, the car can sprint 0-62mph in just 8.5 seconds, meaning it feels far from sluggish.
Out on the road, this characterful petrol offers plenty of pull when accelerating and is eager to rev. It's an easy car to drive and have fun with when behind the wheel, with the Q2 feeling agile in the corners at speeds and well balanced around tight city streets. Comfort is good too, although on 17in wheels like our car here, the ride can get a little bumpy, especially for those in the rear.
The star however is the firm's automatic seven-speed gearbox, the S-Tronic. Its swift, smooth gear changes are an excellent pairing with this engine and make day-to-day driving more rela, especially in start-stop traffic, plus a flick into 'S' mode and a new urgency from the gearbox really adds to the overall driving experience.
Like most Audis, this Q2 features the Drive Select system that offers five different modes - efficiency, auto, comfort, dynamic and individual - which, in the Q2's case, make real tangible differences to the suspension and engine settings. Select Dynamic to accompany the 'S' mode in the gearbox, and you've got an overall engaging and responsive drive.
However, all this sporty driving has taken its toll on my average fuel economy, which has dipped into the 30s when I've been enjoying myself around my local country lanes a little too much.
Our average fuel consumption: 41.8mpg
Update 4: The multistorey challenge
It doesn't take a genius to work out that SUVs are very fashionable at the moment. They are no longer known just for their off-road capabilities, however; a lot of the SUVs of today take a 'style over substance' approach.
Take our Q2. It's an SUV designed for city living, thanks to its compact dimensions and low running costs - two things you would never have associated with the SUVs of old.
Not only does the Q2's small turning circle help navigate tight city streets, but its 4.19m length means Audi's baby SUV is easy to squeeze into cramped parking spaces and can tackle even the trickiest of multistorey car parks.
Sharing a great deal of its underpinnings with its sister car, the A3 Sportback, the Q2 drives, unsurprisingly, very much like a compact hatchback, with the added luxury of more headroom. As is the case with most modern Audis, the Q2 comes with progressive steering, which varies the amount of input needed by the driver, depending on the speed of the car.
The end result is a car with light, responsive steering that is simple to drive, especially in the city.
If the car's steering set-up and small dimensions didn't make parking easy enough, driving aids are also on hand. At the top of the list is the reversing camera, a must for anyone who isn't confident with parallel or bay parking, which costs an extra £395. Standard on the Q2 in S Line spec are rear parking sensors, which should be essential kit for any fleet, as well as Audi's pre-sense front system with pedestrian detection, a clever technology that uses sensors to detect people or other vehicles. If an impending collision is detected, it warns the driver with audible beeps and can even initiate braking.
However, if you want to take the stress completely out of parking, then Park Assist is the system for you. The technology uses the car's many sensors to search for a car parking space and then performs the steering action autonomously, leaving the driver only responsible for the accelerator pedal and working the brakes, and pressing the button to activate the system in the first place, of course. It couldn't be easier and is a bargain at £450, we think.
Our average fuel consumption: 43.7mpg
Update 3: Generation Z
The term 'millennial' has been thrown around a lot recently to describe the latest generation of car buyers that have grown up in a digital age. These savvy buyers have moved away from traditional ownership, and prioritise technology and connectivity above anything else - or so the experts say anyway.
However, we all know that when it comes to choosing your next company car, unless you're carefree and single, it's never really your decision - millennial or not.
Alongside your partner, your children's opinion will be one of the biggest influences - after all, everyone wants to be the parent with the 'cool' car, especially when the kids reach those dreaded teenage years.
Eager to find out what's important to the next generation - or Generation Z to give them their official name - I asked my 15-year-old stepdaughter what she thinks of the trendiest (apparently this is an acceptable term for someone over 30) member of the granitekitchen fleet - the Audi Q2.
The first thing that received praise was the bodystyle - SUVs are in fashion at the moment, after all - and the second was the Q2's compact dimensions; a mini SUV is apparently very 'cute'.
Most teenagers today are very brand aware and even though they cannot drive yet, manufacturers like Audi, Mercedes-Benz and BMW attract more admiration than most - the school run is proof of this. Even if the Q2 was stripped of all luxuries and tech, it would still be the first choice over the Ford Focus also sitting in our driveway.
Luckily our Q2 doesn't scrimp in the kit department. In the S Line trim, our car comes with plenty of equipment as standard, including stylish LED headlights that are particularly popular, front sports seats in part-leather upholstery (another feature that has received praise) and Apple CarPlay, something that is now deemed essential for any car by the next generation of drivers.
The biggest hit in terms of kit, though, is wireless charging, which forms part of the Technology Pack (£1,395). Frustratingly. it will only work with the most modern phones, which I don't own but, of course, most teenagers do, and it's proving invaluable to help keep the kids connected - well worth the investment.
I rarely get things right in my stepdaughter's eyes, especially when it comes to my taste in music or fashion sense; however, the Audi Q2 seems to be the exception to the rule.
Our average fuel consumption: 44.3mpg
Update 2: Baby on board
You wouldn't be alone in thinking that, being the smallest member of the Audi SUV family, the Q2's main strengths lie in personalisation and design, and not in the practicality department.
Boot space, at 405 litres, is significantly smaller than the BMW X1, Mercedes-Benz GLA and MINI Countryman, the Q2's more obvious rivals. However, it trumps many of its compact SUV mainstream rivals, like the Renault Captur, Seat Arona and Hyundai Kona, and betters most C-segment hatchbacks, like the Ford Focus and Volkswagen Golf.
The brochure tells us this is more than enough space for a large suitcase or the weekly shop; however, a new addition to the family meant I could find out first-hand just how practical the Q2 is for family travel.
Having a baby is life-changing for any couple and it's amazing how much stuff somebody so small needs. So a practical car is a must.
The good news is that the Q2 can easily accommodate a modern baby-travel system with room for a few bags if out on a shopping trip. The boot lip is fairly low too, making easy work of lifting the travel system chassis in and out; meanwhile, the clips inside help secure anything fragile. The only downside is if the pram part is needed the parcel shelf has to be removed to be able to fit it all inside. If more boot space is needed, though, the rear seats can be easily collapsed to liberate up to 1,050 litres of space.
Fitting the car seat also proved a doddle (after a bit of practice), thanks to the Audi's Isofix points and, although it's not the most spacious of cars in the rear, my teenage stepdaughter, who is taller than me, has had no grumbles about roominess so far.
There are plenty of storage options throughout the front of the cabin for keys, purses and paperwork, while the rear footwells can accommodate the new changing bag that carries everything but the kitchen sink. The only complaint is the lack of storage options and cupholders in the rear, an issue for a 15-year-old, but not so much for my four-week old son.
Our average fuel consumption: 43.2mpg
Update 1: Welcome
"Why on earth did you choose yellow?"
That was the first question my husband asked on returning home with our latest addition to the granitekitchen fleet. My reply was, "Why not?"
The days of the typical company car being a D-segment saloon or C-segment hatchback, in only sombre black or silver colours and fitted solely with a 1.6 or 2.0-litre diesel engine under the bonnet, are long gone. Drivers have so much more influence over what car they can choose these days and, because of the advancements across the board in engine technology, and the gaps getting tighter for whole-life costs, choice lists have been blown wide open.
It's never been a better time to be a user-chooser and design has become a fundamental part of the decision process, leaving cars like the Q2 hot property on user-chooser lists.
It's not just the 'Vegas Yellow' paintwork that grabs attention either (although it's got very mixed reviews so far with friends and family), there are a number of distinctive features that are likely to turn heads, like the wide tailgate, coloured C-pillar panel and familiar Audi grille design.
Helping to further drive appeal is the fact that the Q2 is a compact SUV, a sector that is still showing considerable growth in the UK.
Like the rest of its family, the Q2 boasts premium appeal with excellent quality throughout. Our new long-term car is in top-of-the range S Line trim and comes with part-leather sports seats, Apple CarPlay, cruise control and parking sensors as standard. Admittedly, there are better-equipped cars for the cash; however, options are reasonable and our latest long-termer is fitted with just under £4,000 worth of them.
We've added important safety features like park assist and a rear-view camera, both very keenly priced at just £150 and £350 respectively, and also opted for adaptive cruise control at £375, another must for many fleets today.
The Technology Pack is the most expensive option at £1,395 and incorporates some of our favourite features introduced to Audi cars over the past couple of years, including the excellent Virtual Cockpit display, wireless charging and the upgraded sat-nav system.
Early impressions of the 1.4-litre petrol under the bonnet of the car are good, too. The 150hp and 250Nm of torque provide plenty of get-up-and-go, while the seven-speed S-Tronic gearbox seems well matched and timely in its gearchanges. We've only driven the car a few miles so far, so it'll be interesting to find out just how versatile the engine is over longer distances and more challenging terrain than the flatlands of Lincolnshire. The ride has been the biggest surprise, though, proving very comfortable despite sitting on 18in alloys.
The engine is fitted with clever 'cylinder on demand' technology, which deactivates two of the engines four cylinders when not required, helping to keep running costs low. The figures in question are 52.3mpg on the official NEDC combined cycle and 123g/km, meaning a 23% BIK tax band until April this year - very competitive numbers overall.
Practicality is seemingly the Q2's biggest downfall, though. At 4.19m long, it's 13cm shorter than the A3 hatchback sibling with which it shares its mechanical underpinnings; however, the Q2 actually offers a boot that is 25 litres bigger than the A3. At 405 litres, it is still small for its class, but should prove big enough for most small families.
It's early days in our six-month custodianship with the Q2 but so far it's proving to be a little ray of sunshine on the granitekitchen fleet. We're looking forward to finding out how it fares under all sorts of everyday life scenarios and to see if there's anything that can take the shine out of that bright yellow paintwork.
Audi Q2 1.4TFSI 150 S-Tronic S Line
P11D price: £28,795
As tested: £32,620
Official consumption: 52.3mpg
Our average consumption: N/A
Standard equipment: LED headlights, front sports seats, sat-nav, Audi Drive Select, Apple CarPlay, parking sensors, cruise control, air-con, part-leather upholstery
Options: Vegas Yellow Solid paintwork (£550), adaptive cruise control (£375), Comfort and Sound Pack (£995), sports steering wheel (£150), park assist (£150), rear-view camera (£350), Technology Pack (£1,395)